Switching billing companies is a cash decision, not a software decision. The risk is not the new contract. The risk is a claim that nobody owns while the old company is leaving and the new one has not started.
If you run a practice and the monthly report no longer matches what hits the bank, this guide is the order of work. It covers when a switch is worth it, what to collect before you give notice, and how to set a cutoff so open claims do not expire.
Quick Answer
- Switch when you cannot see the work. If you cannot match collections to deposits, name who owns your account, or see why claims were written off, the fee is no longer the main problem.
- Set a date-of-service cutoff and put in writing which company works every claim on each side of that date.
- Pull your files before access ends: claim history, remits, open A/R, fee schedules, appeal letters, and payer portal logins that belong to the practice.
- Medicare fee-for-service claims must be filed no later than one calendar year after the date of service. A claim left between two companies can miss that window. Commercial and Medicaid limits are shorter and are set by the plan and your contract.
- Sign a Business Associate Agreement before the next company sees patient information.
Thinking about a move? Bring last month’s totals to a free demo and we will walk through what a cutoff would look like for your payers. Book a free 30-minute demo or see medical billing services.
Table of Contents
- Signs It Is Time to Switch
- What to Compare Besides the Fee
- What to Pull Before You Give Notice
- How to Set the Cutoff
- Who Works the Claims Already in A/R
- Questions to Ask the Next Company
- Mistakes That Cost Money
- How Radiant RCM Handles a Move
- FAQs
Signs It Is Time to Switch
One slow month is not a reason to leave. A pattern you cannot explain is. These are the patterns practice owners usually notice first.
- The report and the bank do not match. Collections on the statement are higher than deposits, and nobody can show the difference.
- You cannot name the person who owns your account this week. Replies come from a shared inbox, and each person asks for the same payer details again.
- Write-offs have no reason you can read. A large adjustment line with no denial code is often a claim nobody appealed.
- Days in A/R keep rising while charges look busy. Our guides use 40 days as a common target. Your specialty and your insurers can change what is realistic. See how to reduce days in A/R.
- You hear about problems from patients, not from the billing company. Eligibility, authorizations, and expiring credentials show up as complaints instead of as a warning.
- Claims sit until a filing deadline is close. Medicare fee-for-service claims must be received no later than one calendar year after the date of service. A late Medicare claim is generally not payable and is not a normal appeal.
- You were told to change EHRs with no reason tied to your payers or your workflow.
If two or more of these have been true for a quarter, price the switch. Start with last month’s numbers, not with a sales call. The free Money Leak Check uses those totals and does not need patient details.
What to Compare Besides the Fee
A lower percentage can still leave you with less cash if the new company does not work denials. Put two quotes next to the same month of collections, then compare the work, not only the rate. The fee ranges and the contract traps are in how much medical billing costs.
For the switch itself, compare four things:
- Reporting. You should see charges, payments, denials by reason, and A/R aging by payer. A single collections number is not a report.
- A named contact who already knows your specialty, not a rotating pool.
- Your systems stay. The company should work in the EHR and clearinghouse you already use, unless there is a specific payer reason to change.
- The exit. Notice period, your files, and what happens to open claims if you leave later. If leaving is vague now, it will be expensive later.
If you are also weighing an in-house biller, use in-house vs outsourced medical billing for the full cost, including salary, software, and time off.
What to Pull Before You Give Notice
Read the current contract before you tell anyone you are leaving. Note the notice period, any termination fee, and who is allowed to keep working claims after the end date.
Then save copies while you still have access:
- Open A/R by payer, with age and claim status
- A recent month of charges, payments, and adjustments that you can tie to bank deposits
- Denial and write-off reports by reason code
- Remittance files (ERAs and EOBs) and the fee schedules you are paid under
- Appeal letters and the status of each open appeal
- Payer portal, clearinghouse, and ERA/EFT access that is in the practice’s name
- Provider credentialing and enrollment records
If the clearinghouse or the electronic deposits are in the billing company’s name, move them back to the practice before the last day. A company that resists a claim-level export is telling you what the handoff will feel like.
How to Set the Cutoff
Pick a date of service, not a vague “go live when ready.” Example: the new company submits every claim for dates of service on or after June 1. The current company keeps every claim for dates of service before June 1, through its notice period.
Write that split down and send it to both companies. Include:
- The cutoff date
- Who submits new claims
- Who posts payments during the overlap
- Who answers payer calls for each side of the cutoff
- The date payer portal and clearinghouse access changes
- The first report you will receive, and what it must contain
Do not cut the old company off on a Friday and hope the new one is enrolled on Monday. Payer enrollment and ERA setup take time. The new company should already have secure access to your EHR and a signed Business Associate Agreement before the cutoff.
Who Works the Claims Already in A/R
This is the step practices skip, and it is where cash disappears. Every open claim needs one owner.
- Option A: the current company finishes claims it already submitted, and the new company takes only new dates of service. Use this when the old company is still responsive and the contract requires them to finish the work.
- Option B: the new company takes a defined bucket of old A/R, such as claims older than 60 days, at a price you agreed before the start. Get the bucket, the rate, and the filing deadlines in the proposal.
Do not leave “someone will look at the old claims” in an email. Appeals in progress need a named owner and the letters that have already been sent. A second company that restarts an appeal without the file can miss the payer’s appeal window.
Baseline the month you switch. Write down net collection rate, days in A/R, and the denial mix from the KPI guide. Judge the new company against those numbers, not against a promise made before they saw your claims.
Questions to Ask the Next Company
- Who is our day-to-day contact, and do they already bill our specialty?
- Will you work in our current EHR and clearinghouse?
- Which dates of service will you submit, and who works everything older than that?
- Is old A/R included in the quote, or priced separately?
- What will the first monthly report show, and can we tie it to our deposits?
- Will you sign a Business Associate Agreement before anyone on your team sees patient information?
- Are ERA deposits and the clearinghouse account in our name?
- How much notice do we give if we leave, and what files do we receive on the way out?
For the fee side of those questions, including what “percentage of collections” is taken from, use the pricing guide.
Mistakes That Cost Money
- Giving notice before you have the files. Access is the first thing that changes.
- Two companies submitting the same date of service. That creates duplicate claims and delayed payment.
- No owner for appeals already in progress.
- Changing bank deposits and the clearinghouse in the same week as the first claims, with nobody confirming the payers received the new setup.
- Judging the first month by collections alone. Old claims still paying from the previous company can make a weak start look fine, or a clean start look slow.
- Sending patient files through a public website form before a Business Associate Agreement is signed.
How Radiant RCM Handles a Move
Radiant RCM starts by learning your workflow, payer mix, and specialty, then sets up secure access to the EHR, clearinghouse, and billing system you already use. You do not need to change systems for us to bill. We work with Tebra (Kareo), Practice Fusion, DrChrono, athenahealth, eClinicalWorks, NextGen, Epic, Oracle Cerner, Meditech Expanse, WebPT, SimplePractice, and TherapyNotes. If yours is not on that list, ask us and we will confirm.
You get a dedicated account manager and reports on charges, payments, denials, and A/R. Where required, we enter into a Business Associate Agreement before handling protected health information.
Pricing is pay-for-paid. It includes free software installation and denial appeals. The final cost depends on your provider type, the number of insurance plans, and the services you need. On the demo, ask who will work open A/R and which date of service the new claims start. Bring last month’s totals. Do not send patient records through the website form.
Book a free 30-minute demo or read more about outsourced medical billing.
Final Thoughts
Leave when you cannot see the work. Before you give notice, save the files, pick a date-of-service cutoff, and name one owner for every open claim. The new fee matters less than whether those claims are still payable when the handoff is done.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should a practice switch medical billing companies?
Switch when you cannot reconcile reports to deposits, cannot name who owns your account, or cannot see why claims were written off, and that has lasted more than a single slow month. Rising days in A/R and problems you hear about first from patients are the same kind of signal.
How do you switch medical billing companies without losing claims?
Set a date-of-service cutoff, put in writing which company works claims on each side of that date, and export open A/R, remits, and appeal files before access ends. Do not have two companies submit the same dates of service.
Who should work old insurance claims during a switch?
One company, named in writing. Either the current company finishes claims it already submitted, or the new company takes a defined aging bucket at a price you agreed up front. Appeals already in progress need the letters and a single owner.
What files should we download before we give notice?
Open A/R, a recent month of charges and payments, denial and write-off reports, remittance files, fee schedules, appeal status, credentialing records, and payer portal or clearinghouse access that belongs to the practice.
Do we have to change our EHR to switch billing companies?
No. A billing company should be able to work in the EHR you already use unless there is a specific reason tied to your payers or workflow. Radiant RCM bills in the systems practices already use, including Tebra (Kareo), athenahealth, eClinicalWorks, DrChrono, Epic, and WebPT.
How long does Medicare give a practice to file a claim?
Medicare fee-for-service claims must be filed no later than one calendar year after the date of service, with limited exceptions. A claim that sits unassigned during a switch can miss that deadline. Commercial and Medicaid filing limits are set by the plan and your contract, and they are often shorter.
Sources
- 42 CFR 424.44 — Medicare time limits for filing claims
- Medicare.gov, Filing a claim — the 12-month filing timeframe
- U.S. HHS, Business Associates — when a billing company must have a Business Associate Agreement
- How much medical billing costs — rates, pricing models, and contract fees
Privacy Notice: Please do not submit patient records, insurance information, medical details, claim files, or other protected health information through the public website form. Review the Radiant RCM Privacy Policy before submitting an inquiry.
This article provides general information for practice owners. Filing deadlines, contract terms, and handoff steps vary by payer, specialty, and agreement. Examples are illustrative. Confirm your contract and current payer rules before you give notice or share patient information.



